Taurus – A Parable of Freedom of Speech
A mouthful of water makes the traveler splutter. A koi fish leaps restlessly in a shallow pond. This proverb fits aptly when applied to those lecherous theoreticians—or rather, pompous intellectual mandarins—who compelled the authorities of the Kolkata Film Festival to withdraw Russian director Alexander Sokurov’s Taurus. The film painstakingly portrays the crippled body, helplessness, insecurity, despair, and uncertainty of Lenin, the Bolshevik hero, in his final days. It lays bare the character of Lenin as both a representative of bourgeois society and leader of the proletariat. Sokurov’s fault lay in showing the prophet of Marxism not as a grand messiah, but as a mortal of flesh and blood—one who makes mistakes, seeks atonement, and is far from optimistic about the world. In Bengal, the so-called “Stupid Federation of India”—a communist student body whose members often pronounce and even write “Lenin” as Lelin—passed judgment on the film without seeing it, or at best wi...